Story Photos
 Cliff Wheeler photographed this limping elk east of Castle Rock in June. The elk's left rear hoof is misshapen. Photo courtesy of Larry Gitch
|
Past Month's Most Commented Stories
- Protesters hold 'tea party' in Clatskanie (185)
- Breaking news: Toledo man shoots, kills burglar (147)
- Swine flu's likely here; local supply of seasonal flu vaccine wiped out (97)
- Dozens at rally urge rejection of Referendum 71 (95)
- Voters approve Referendum 71 (91)
- Castle Rock man gets citation for killing deer within Kelso city limits (87)
- How to vote on Ref. 71 is confusing many (78)
- Gay rights supporters hoping narrow lead holds (78)
- Controversial speaker warns about 'threat of Islam' (68)
- 15-year-old arrested for alleged attempted murder (59)
Hoof rot has become common problem for region's elk
Friday, November 6, 2009 12:16 AM PST
By Tom Paulu
Printable version
E-mail this articleLarry Gitch spent three August weekends in the Boistfort area in Lewis County scouting elk.
“I would say in 60 percent or better of the animals, I would see hoof rot,” said Gitch, a Vancouver resident who had a master hunter elk permit for an area near Vader.
“Some of them did not want to put their feet on the ground,” Gitch said. “Some of them would actually drag their feet. ... It’s a pretty sad deal. It was just hard to watch at times.”
Hunters who head out for the modern rifle general bull elk season, which opens Saturday in Western Washington, are likely to see animals in the same condition.
Biologists, hunters and wildlife watchers are seeing more Southwest Washington elk with misshapen, sometimes crossing hooves.
“In the past three years it’s become really acute,” said Pat Miller, a wildlife biologist for the Department of Fish and Wildlife.
The condition seems most common in the lowlands east and west of Interstate 5, Miller said.
Last summer, one of Cliff Wheeler’s motion-activated cameras photographed the cow elk pictured above. The camera was set up in the woods near Wheeler’s Tower Road home, east of Castle Rock.
Mark Smith, who lives at his Eco Park resort near the Toutle River 20 miles east of the freeway, said he’s seen hoof rot in that area. “I’ve seen it all the way from the (Weyerhaeuser) Forest Learning Center all the way down the valley,” Smith said.
Gitch said a friend who recently spent a week hunting with a Mount Whittier tag north of Spirit Lake didn’t see any hoof rot in the elk there.
The WDFW has sent surveys to hunters to learn more about how far hoof rot has spread.
Hoof rot hasn’t been observed in elk elsewhere in the United States, said Kristin Mansfield, a WDFW veterinarian based in Spokane.
However, a similar condition has been seen in moose from Southeast Alaska, Mansfield said.
Last spring, WDFW biologists shot eight elk in the Castle Rock, Vader and Pe Ell areas and collected tissue samples to study hoof rot. Five of the animals had misshapen hooves and the others appeared healthy.
“We didn’t get any straight answers,” Mansfield said. “We were able to rule out a few things.” For instance, she doesn’t think the condition is caused by a genetic problem or toxic plants the elk ate.
Some of the animals had mineral deficiencies, Miller said.
Hoof rot appears in both bull and cow elk of all ages, Mansfield said.
More than 40 types of hoof rot afflict wild and domestic animals.
Hoof rot that elk get is similar to a type seen in domestic sheep, Mansfield said, though the progression of the condition is reversed.
Sheep hoof rot starts with a bacterial infection.
With the elk, hooves don’t wear normally, which allows bacteria to get into them. “It almost seems as if they grow too long first,” Mansfield said.
Increased levels of hoof rot haven’t been reported in local cattle and sheep, and it isn’t a health hazard to humans, Mansfield said.
Because it’s painful for them to walk, elk with hoof rot have trouble foraging and are sometimes emaciated.
Gitch said some of the Boistfort elk he saw “were so sick you could see their haunches.”
Possible causes of elk hoof rot include nutritional deficiencies, dietary changes and either decreased activity or more walking on soft soils, Mansfield wrote in a paper on the subject.
Smith said his research suggests overpopulation and lack of nutrition are causing the hoof rot. Smith and other members of the Mount St. Helens Preservation Society feed elk at Eco Park during winter months. Last winter, an elk that could barely walk improved after several weeks of getting hay.
But the WDFW isn’t ready to suggest how elk can recovery without more research. In any case, Mansfield said treatments for free-ranging wildlife are limited. “It’s difficult to do any hands-on things like trim the hoofs.”
Elk with hoof rot may not look healthy, but the meat from unaffected parts of their bodies is safe to eat.
Hunters’ “eyes and their nose are their best guide to whether that part of the elk is appropriate to eat,” Miller said. “If it doesn’t smell right, throw it out. There are some herds that have a lot of limping elk.”
Gitch shot an elk with hoof rot and asked his meat cutter for advice. The butcher told him the meat above the hoof rot joints was OK.
“I’ve eaten it and it’s no problem at all,” Gitch said.
Me who else? wrote on Nov 6, 2009 7:03 AM:
us citizen wrote on Nov 6, 2009 7:09 AM:
CRfisherman wrote on Nov 6, 2009 7:56 AM:
Atrucker wrote on Nov 6, 2009 11:23 AM:
And we all know a fungus is very hard to kill . Culling the herds not a bad idea , but to out right kill them all as us citizen suggests is just plain stupid and your talking about a lot of elk. "
us citizen wrote on Nov 6, 2009 12:31 PM:
hmtcherof2 wrote on Nov 6, 2009 7:08 PM:
Brian wrote on Nov 8, 2009 11:26 AM:
Limit the COW elk hunts to those elk showing clearly visable signs of hoof rot only. Why not change the forest practices to inclued a min of 10% planted, managed grass land for logged areas greater than 100 AC. NO I am not a liberal!!! I do question the managment practices of Wildlife and forest lands. Thank you! "
carharttkid629 wrote on Nov 17, 2009 3:53 PM:
The copper-sulfate mentioned works on cattle but I know copper is highly toxic to sheep so I don't know about elk
Just my $.02 "
Note: when we post a new story on the same topic, comments don't move to the new page. For comments that won't be tied to the story, try our community forum; signing up is quick and free.