Longview Weather
79°F
Severe
Full Forecaste

Story Photos

The amputation of a front leg hasn’t slowed down Ella, 2. Greg Ebersole / The Daily News

Home > Area News

'Poor dog' takes horrible accident in stride

Thursday, May 8, 2008 11:31 PM PDT

By Amy M.E. Fischer

Font Size:

The black dog launches herself across the grass at Lake Sacajawea.

The tennis ball soars hundreds of feet, and the dog is already halfway there. She snatches up the prize and races back to her owners. The ball flies again, and Ella shoots off, her feet a blur, her face the picture of doggy joy.

It’s then you realize she’s got only three legs.

People walking the lake do a double-take. “Poor dog,” their expressions say.

But Ella, a 2-year-old black lab/pitbull mix, doesn’t spend time mourning her amputated front leg—not while there’s ball to play, rivers to swim, cars to ride in, a couch to sleep on and people to snuggle with.

Ella drops the ball at David Swanson’s feet, panting heavily, tail wagging. Her eyes are fastened on the soggy tennis ball as Swanson’s 15-year-old daughter, Hannah Bennett-Swanson, inserts it into the plastic throwing arm.

“She’s relentless with the ball. She’ll go forever,” said Swanson, 53, a Longview cabinet and furniture maker.

But one terrible evening last July, Swanson’s family feared Ella’s ball-chasing days were over.

‘I thought she was gonna die’

It had been a beautiful summer day. Hannah and her mom, Anne Bennett, took Ella hiking on the trails around Rainier High School and then ran an errand.

They returned to Longview, pulled into the driveway of their Old West Side home and opened the car door. Ella jumped out and ran across the street to inspect a roaming cat.

Bennett crossed 24th Avenue to get her. A pickup approached, and Bennett held up her hand. The truck stopped. As Bennett reached for Ella’s collar, she motioned for the truck to drive on.

Ella ran in front of the truck.

Inside the house, Swanson heard the dog scream, followed by the screams of his wife and daughter.

Ella’s front right leg was dangling, its muscles and tendons exposed.

Swanson called to her, but the panicked, wounded dog took off running toward the lake. Her family gave chase, Hannah and her dad on foot, Bennett in the car. Hearing their cries, neighbors joined in pursuit. Hannah called out to passersby, asking if they’d seen Ella.

Block after block Ella ran. She crossed the steel bridge at Hemlock Plaza and descended the bank into the cool water.

“I thought she was gonna die. I was really, really, really sad,” said Hannah, a sophomore at R.A. Long High School who had begged her parents for another dog after the family’s elderly black lab passed away. In July 2006 they adopted Ella from the Cowlitz County Humane Society. The 8-week-old nugget of black fur had a cold and a touch of mange. Out of a litter of 11, Ella was one of two puppies to survive.

At the lake, Swanson pulled Ella from the shallow water and carried her to the car. A neighbor, Tim Temples, wrapped Ella’s leg in Ace bandages. Hannah and Swanson held the dog in the back seat for the 40-minute drive to an emergency veterinarian in Vancouver, the closest animal hospital open in the evenings.

The veterinarian looked at the X-rays and declared Ella’s leg could not be saved. Swanson and Bennett debated whether to euthanize Ella. Hannah said absolutely not.

The next day, a Longview veterinarian amputated Ella’s leg. The family brought Ella home with a cone around her head to keep her from chewing at her staples.

“They said there are a lot of three legged dogs that do just fine,” Swanson recalled.

While Ella rested, Bennett, a physician recruiter, sat down at her computer to research dogs with missing limbs. She was encouraged by what she found — an online community of people with amputee pets. Bennett marveled at a video someone posted of a two-legged greyhound. The dog was missing both legs on one side, and it was running, said Bennett, 54.

Living a great life

Soon, Ella’s incisions healed and the vet removed the staples. That day, the family took her to Northlake Elementary School and set her loose.

“She got used to it really fast, but a couple times she stumbled,” Hannah said.

Getting to this point had cost more than $3,000 in vet bills, but Ella was ready to run.

Now, Swanson walks Ella every morning at the lake. The sight of her happily trotting along on three legs tends to make people grateful for what they have and less inclined to complain about their minor troubles, he said.

“When you think about how she just does what she could do before and doesn’t think about it—she doesn’t let the loss of a leg stop her,” Swanson said. “She’s not smart enough to think about it,” he chuckled.

Wiped out from playing fetch Tuesday afternoon, Ella sprawled out on the cool wood floor beneath the dining room table.

“People say, ‘Oh, poor dog,’” Bennett said. “We start laughing because she’s got such a great life.”

Previous Next

Kelso MOM wrote on May 9, 2008 1:16 AM:

" what an amazing story!!! You go girl!!! "

cat lover wrote on May 9, 2008 1:25 AM:

" For those that would like to take in a 3 legged sweetheart of a cat. There is one up for adoption at Kitty Korner/ Humane society! She/he is a real sweetie and jumped into my lap when I was filling out adoption papers on our cat we had already picked out! I would love to see she/he adopted!!! "

wendee wrote on May 9, 2008 1:45 AM:

" Ella is so lucky to have such a great family. Not many would be willing to pay that much money on medical bills for a pet... I feel small because I'm not sure that I would have. I hope you have many many wonderful years together. Bless you "

mit wrote on May 9, 2008 4:41 AM:

" Thanks for the story. I enjoyed it!!! "

Kudos wrote on May 9, 2008 6:00 AM:

" What a great family for making this decision in giving young Ella a chance at life! "

Nothing new wrote on May 9, 2008 6:06 AM:

" My cat lost her last leg in a tragic accident, as well. It was one of her hind legs. It slowed her down a bit, but she gets around just fine now. This is nothing new, really. "

Amazed By Ignorance wrote on May 9, 2008 7:15 AM:

" Ok. I'm glad for the mutt, and it's a "feel good" story. However, is this really newsworthy, or just an excuse to practice some creative writing? Since when do "dogs scream"? "

DAVID wrote on May 9, 2008 7:24 AM:

" RIGHT ON,RIGHT ON, RIGHT ON.Tough dog and good people.Thats pretty much all there is to say.It's all in the heart baby!!!Heart of the dog to keep on keepin on and heart of people to spend $3000.They deserve each other,I love it!!! "

book chick wrote on May 9, 2008 8:06 AM:

" This story is a day brightener! Ella is a sweetheart. Thanks! "

I beg to differ with you wrote on May 9, 2008 8:10 AM:

" "She's not smart enough to think about it"...I'm so happy to say how wrong you are...here's an adjustment to thought: Ella's smart enough to know there's NO POINT IN THINKING ABOUT IT! :) :) Rock on Bennett-Swanson Family! Thank you for seeing the value in Ella's life and allowing her to continue to contribute more to yours...and ours! "

Get a life wrote on May 9, 2008 9:02 AM:

" So I open up the paper today and read a well-written, feel-good story to brighten my Friday and yet some people STILL can't start their day off without finding something to complain about! I am astonished by how many negative people live here. It is a beautiful Friday, the birds are singing and rather than enjoy it, you have to complain about an article about a THREE LEGGED DOG! "

Re Amazed wrote on May 9, 2008 9:05 AM:

" I am probably not the only one truly amazed by YOUR ignorance. In my opinion, you are a waste of time. "

CathyZ wrote on May 9, 2008 9:32 AM:

" I loved reading a story about my little friend Ella, whom I see scampering around the lake. Great writing, great details, terrific picture of Ella! "

To Amazed By Ignorance wrote on May 9, 2008 9:34 AM:

" Let me correct you "Amazed By Ignorance" My dog does literally "scream," it is not a howl nor a whimpering cry, but an all out scream louder than any human you could possibly imagine. He has a little anxiety problem :-) To the family of this beautiful Ella, thank you for giving your buddy another chance at life. Oh and by the way....this is just another reason why we need an Emergency Vet in town! "

yakvetnurse wrote on May 9, 2008 10:03 AM:

" to "Amazed by Ignorance"....As an emergency veterinary nurse, I can assure you that dogs DO "scream." Igorance....hmmm....lol. "

a college neighbor... wrote on May 9, 2008 10:11 AM:

" had a dog that had the same leg amputated and it also didn't slow it down a bit. Animals are amazing....if it were mine I'd have the work done in a second, regardless of the bills. Mine is more like a kid than a pet. TDN, thank you for printing a story that makes people feel good. With so much crap in this world, it's nice to see that there are still some thing out there worth seeing and reading about. "

Emergency vet available wrote on May 9, 2008 10:21 AM:

" Valley Vet in Rainier is available for after-hours emergency care. I don't know why everyone insists that Vancouver is the only emergency vet available! "

TO Amazed by ignorance wrote on May 9, 2008 10:31 AM:

" I am saddened that you can't see the good in this story! I would so much rather open the Daily News and read this then something about a drug bust or something horrible. It made me smile, therefore it was newsworthy! I am not the only person it made smile! What an awesome story. Thank you DN for printing it! It is nice to see positive nice things in the paper! People who write negative are pretty sad people. "

Amazed By Ignorance wrote on May 9, 2008 10:44 AM:

" I was questioning the newsworthiness of the story, and the wording used. I know dogs to howl, growl, whimper, etc. If some think they "scream", fine. Seemed like the terminology in question by myself was a bit to much a practice in artistic liberty. I know people tend to "humanize" their furry family members. I am genuinely happy for the dog, as I am an animal lover, and a pet owner. Breathe, people...it was just an observation. "

Spirit wrote on May 9, 2008 10:55 AM:

" A Super terrific story! Certainly brightened my day!

Thanks!
"

NZ wrote on May 9, 2008 11:00 AM:

" I loved the story. I don't think I would call Ella a "poor dog," though. She seems happy and healthy, and has a wonderful family to take care of her. It is nice to read about happy things once in awhile. Well done! "

Kelso Nana wrote on May 9, 2008 11:11 AM:

" What a GREAT "feel good" story! Both Ella and family are lucky to have each other! How sad for "amazed" that he/she has to be so negative. There's way too much negative in this world these days. Thanks to TDN for printing a such a great article! "

wondering wrote on May 9, 2008 11:23 AM:

" Why is the dog off leash? "

CR girl wrote on May 9, 2008 11:38 AM:

" Beautiful story! Beautiful people! Beautiful doggie!
"

dogs DO scream wrote on May 9, 2008 11:43 AM:

" Amazed by Ignorance should watch this video and see that dogs (especially pugs) DO scream: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ignq4xXmgxI
"

to Amazed And Ignorant wrote on May 9, 2008 11:49 AM:

" It's not anthropomorphism; dogs can & sometimes do scream. Their natural instinct is to hide pain so they don't appear vulnerable to potential predators (or lower-ranking pack members seeking higher status), so they typically won't scream unless they're in excruciating pain or mortal distress. If you've never heard a dog scream, be thankful. It's way beyond a mere yip or yelp & it's definitely not a sound you ever want to hear coming from your dog. "

EX-LONGVIEW-ITE wrote on May 9, 2008 1:16 PM:

" I live in the Tri-Cities now.. and Chocolate.. the lab dog found in a field with both legs broke and no medical attention for 6 months..reminds me of this story..
Chocolate is fortunate tho-- the vets at the U.W. fixed him up-- and with therapy he should be adoptable in June.
This dog is also fortunate that someone cared enough to help her.. and I own a cat and a black lab now...so this story is a great one! Thanks Daily News for publishing this touching story! "

Louie wrote on May 9, 2008 2:01 PM:

" A couple of comments...Longview has no leash law and in order to utilize Valley Vet's emergency services I believe you have to be a client and the last I knew they were not taking anymore Washington clients. They are a great bunch at that vet. as I have been a client for about 7 years.
Oh yes...I agree...dogs do scream.
Great story as it goes to show you the spirit of our beloved animals as well as results when a pet is properly cared for. "

Dog fan wrote on May 9, 2008 2:31 PM:

" My family has spent close to $8000 dollars on our two dogs. One needed surgery for swallowing a dog toy, the rest of the money is just check-ups, shots and Frontline and other stuff. WELL WORTH THE MONEY.

Our dogs are part of our family.

What a great story!!!! "

sigh wrote on May 9, 2008 3:26 PM:

" with all of the problems facing this world and the doom and gloom news we get reported about people...the best positive story you can come up with is about a dog??? Yep people suck and animals are better!!!! How about an article about a HUMAN who lost his leg defending his country or following his dreams....a dog????...sigh... "

LL wrote on May 9, 2008 3:53 PM:

" What a cute story!! I'm so glad that the family decided to spend the money to save Ella. My family had to go through years of medical expenses for our diabetic dog. It's heartwarming to see these types of people. And just a side note- I've been a Valley Vet client for YEARS now, and they truly do care, and I believe that even if you are not a client, they are willing to act as an emergency vet service. I mean, these people came out to my house at 2 in the morning when the family's dog had a heart attack and had to be put down.... they are just so amazing and so caring. "

to sigh wrote on May 9, 2008 4:10 PM:

" You obviously don't understand how important dogs (and other animals) are to the lives of some of the people living in our community. After a hard day at work, that's one of the things some of us look forward to when we go home every night. Having a dog in our lives brings us friendship, trust, pure unbridled joy, and, in days of darkness, comfort and reasons to overcome the day. Having a dog gives us reason to rise early, take long walks and look longingly into the future. I hope someday, 'sigh', that you'll understand that it's not "just a dog," like you say, but the thing that gives us humanity and keeps us from being "just a human."

I hope to see Ella and family one morning on our walk around the lake; I'd like to meet with them and share, in person, how proud I am to have such a wonderful, caring family living in our community. Until then! :) "

Fencepost wrote on May 9, 2008 4:53 PM:

" Re: Amazed by Ignorance -- Please don't feed the trolls. "

LOVE IT wrote on May 9, 2008 5:01 PM:

" Great story! Accidents happen and alteast you were responsible pet owners to fork out the cash. They are family members too. I recently had to take my Chocoate Lab in for emergency surgery about 2 months ago. It is SO expenses. Needless to say...I now have pet insurance. "

and wrote on May 9, 2008 6:38 PM:

" Good dog, good folks. "

-legged dog owner wrote on May 9, 2008 7:12 PM:

" My junior had his rear leg amputated after he was hit by a truck. He can still outrun the kids and he is almost faster than the new puppy at 3 years old. A 3-legged dog is just as good, if not better, than a run of the mill 4-legger. "

To Sigh Wondering wrote on May 9, 2008 7:15 PM:

" I wish I could post what I really think about you but the Gestapo would censor it. Great story, Great family & Great dog. "

doggylover wrote on May 9, 2008 7:28 PM:

" I loved this heartwarming story. I myself am an owner of three labs two of which are pitbull mix and would do the same for any one of them. They are like our children. I commend the Bennett-Swanson family. Ella is a beautiful animal and they are beautiful people and Amazed is just ignorant. "

Lindsey wrote on May 9, 2008 11:15 PM:

" You go Ella girl! "

dog lover wrote on May 10, 2008 12:00 PM:

" I attend school with Hannah and i remember when she got Ella she was a beautiful puppy and she is still a beautiful dog, she loved that dog and i'm not surprised that they were willing to spend the money. "

Top Jobs
Top Garage Sales
Top Rentals